And the winner is: Emily B, who preferred the pagoda style!!!!
I'm away at the moment in the Okanagan with very limited wifi access but I'll be in touch with Emily early in the week so I can arrange to send the umbrella!
Thanks to you all for entering. There were 9 qualified entries by the cutoff time. I saved a print screen of the official Random Numbers result but can't figure out how to get it on here ('cuz it's a doc, not a jpeg). Maybe I can edit this later if I can get Scott to fix that for me once I'm back home....
Have a Happy New Year everybody! I'll be back soon and I'm going to try to have more contests or giveaways in the future. I think they're a lot of fun!